Stand in Salisbury's Cathedral Close today and it's hard to imagine this magnificent building almost didn't exist at all. The original Salisbury Cathedral stood four miles away on a windswept hilltop called Old Sarum — and the story of why it was abandoned is one of the most dramatic episodes in English ecclesiastical history.
Life on the Hilltop: Old Sarum's Original Cathedral
When the Normans swept through England after 1066, they brought order — and stone — with them. At Old Sarum, the Iron Age hillfort that the Romans had called Sorviodunum, they built both a royal castle and a cathedral. The first cathedral at Old Sarum was consecrated in 1092, just 26 years after the Conquest. This was a statement of Norman power: church and state sharing the same impregnable hill.
For over a century, it seemed to work. Bishops of Salisbury wielded enormous political power from Old Sarum. Bishop Roger of Salisbury, who served under Henry I, was effectively the second most powerful man in England. The hilltop was busy, important, and fortified.
The Problem With Sharing a Hill With Soldiers
But there were serious tensions. The cathedral and the royal castle sat just metres apart, and relations between the clergy and the soldiers were often hostile. The clergy complained that soldiers blocked their access to their own church. Water was scarce on the hilltop — there was no natural spring, and every drop had to be carried up. The wind on an exposed chalk hill in Wiltshire can be ferocious, and medieval chroniclers record that it regularly blew out candles during services.
Most dramatically, the clergy alleged that soldiers would sometimes lock them out of the cathedral altogether. Imagine being a medieval bishop, unable to reach your own altar because a soldier has bolted the gate.
The Bishop's Vision: A New City in the Valley
In 1217, Bishop Richard Poore formally petitioned Pope Honorius III for permission to move the cathedral. His petition cited the wind, the water shortage, the military harassment, and the fact that the chalky ground was so hard that the dead couldn't easily be buried. Pope Honorius, perhaps understandably, granted permission within two years.
According to legend — and legend it almost certainly is — Bishop Poore shot an arrow from Old Sarum and declared he would build the new cathedral wherever it landed. The arrow supposedly struck a deer, which fled to the water meadows below and died on the spot where the Cathedral now stands. It's a charming story, but the reality is more prosaic: the flat, well-watered land in the valley of the Avon was simply the obvious choice.
Building the World's Fastest Cathedral
Work began on 28 April 1220, when the foundation stones were laid with great ceremony. What happened next was remarkable: the entire cathedral was built in just 38 years, a speed almost without parallel in medieval church construction. Most great cathedrals took a century or more. Canterbury had been under construction for nearly 400 years. Salisbury was essentially built in a single sustained effort, which is why it has a striking architectural unity — one style, one vision, one generation.
The Early English Gothic style throughout the building reflects the fashions of the 1220s–1250s. It was consecrated in 1258 and the spire — the tallest medieval stone spire ever built, at 123 metres — was added between 1285 and 1320.
What Happened to the Old Cathedral?
The original cathedral at Old Sarum was systematically dismantled. Stone was precious in a region with no local quarry, and the old building was essentially a free resource. Much of its stone was reused in the new building or sold. By 1331 the old cathedral had been completely razed. Only its foundations remain today, visible as earthworks within the ancient hillfort.
Old Sarum itself gradually emptied. Without the cathedral to anchor it, and with the new city of Salisbury thriving below, the hilltop community faded away over the 13th and 14th centuries. By 1400 it was effectively abandoned — the origin of the most extraordinary "rotten borough" in later English political history.
